"I've been waiting my entire life to tell you that I'm dying and I figured I'd finally get it over with.
So here I am, carving forgive me
into my teeth, so every time that I speak
I can still say that I'm sorry.
More years have passed in the last than I care to remember
but I could never forget:
In eighth grade my chorus teacher always told me,
'Michael, you'll never be good enough.'
and it always excited me. It reminded me of my mother.
On the last day of school she smiled,
her teeth jagged like a train wreck,
she didn't say a word,
but I knew exactly what she meant.
In high school I fell in love with a roadside bomb waiting to be detonated by a passing glance.
Every time she blew up,
she'd pick the pieces of herself off of bathroom floors
mixed with the medicine she never needed. She had
The Disappointment.
One day she caught me staring, smiled, walked over, and hugged me...
she smelled like a lonely night.
As she pulled away she looked me dead in the eyes and said,
'Don't worry about me boy. I don't hate my life, I just fell in love with stormy weather
and when my head clears up I put it back into the fog where it belongs.'
We made love to each others' broken promises
and I sang her to sleep when she got tired of chasing everything else."
At that point Michael turned to me and asked if it was all a dream
as if saying yes would make it any less real.
I nodded.
At that point he turned away, tied his arm up, and shot the blues directly into his veins.
He sang me to sleep that night. When I woke up
I looked over a section that he hadn't said aloud. It read:
I didn't address this to anyone because it was meant for everyone
and no one at all.
There is a time when it is neither day or night
It just is.
As we are. Forever. Everything
and nothing at all
Today, I believe him.
Yesterday I didn't
and tomorrow I probably won't either
but what I do know is that somewhere,
between Heaven and a hard place,
Michael is singing
and god is wishing he had a voice like that.
I love this piece because it has this mysterious feeling to it. You don't quite understand it much as you read it the first few times, but then an idea sinks in, and this piece gets you thinking. I read this at least ten times, and I'm still thinking.
One thing I'm mulling about is the point of view. It's a little confusing to me, but that's what keeps me wanting to read on. I think that it is just great how you did that. Honestly though, it is a little confusing. But if I'm stupid, please tell me. I am young. ><
My favorite line:
'Don't worry about me boy. I don't hate my life, I just fell in love with stormy weather
and when my head clears up I put it back into the fog where it belongs.'
I am in love with this piece! Please write more, I encourage you to keep striving! ^_^
Next, to address your questions:
The piece does NOT come off as "too much". As a matter of fact, I think you had a great balance here of poetry and reality along with drama and a sort-of coolness.
Yes, the diction does benefit the piece. It helps it feel more poetic and it also helps the flow.
The piece is too long and a little overwritten. I think the piece could be read this way, but I also think that just the stuff Micheal said in the beginning would be great on its own. The last bit was a little confusing too, the "today-tomorrow-yesterday" part.
It is a little difficult to follow who is speaking. The first time I read it, I didn't know who Micheal was when he finished speaking and I was startled at his name until I looked back up and saw what the teacher had said. If you could mention Micheal's name one more time (in the beginning), maybe when she is speaking, it would help a lot.
Punctuation. Commas can be overused in some poems, but your opening text really needed some.
Vision: 4 and a half stars.
Reason: I think you had a very clear idea of where you wanted to go with this and it shows.
Originality: 5 stars.
Reason: It was very original in the way that it was presented and written.
Technique: 4 and a half stars.
Reason: While I thought your technique was very good, I see room for improvement.
Impact: 4 and a half stars.
Reason: The opening text was so emotional and beautiful, but everything else didn't really give me that feeling.
Favorite line:
So here I am, carving forgive me
into my teeth, so every time that I speak
I can still say that I'm sorry.
Again, congrats on the DD!
XOXO,
MSA
Hosting a HUGE contest, 1,000 point grand prize, 5 points for entering!
[link]
The Artist has requested Critique on this Artwork
Please sign up or login to post a critique.